Secret Police & Galactic Resort

from GalCiv2 Forums
I realize this is only beta, but I'm wondering if other people are observing the same things I am:

1) I look at the Secret Police Center and it says, "Improve base morale by 20%". So, my planet is at 59% approval, I buy the Secret Police Center, and now my morale is at 72%. I have no other morale structures on the planet. I'm sorry, but that's only a 13% improvement. It's being multiplied by the base morale, just like everything else. That sort of defeats the purpose when I could have just built a Multimedia Center.

I further confirmed this when I built a Zero G Area together with a Secret Police Center. When I built the Zero G first, morale went up by 19%. When I built the Secret Police first and then the Zero G, morale from the Zero G went up by 19%. The Secret Police did not affect it.

2) The Galactic Resort is the same way. It says, "Improve morale by 25%", so at least it doesn't CLAIM to improve base morale, but...what's the point? I can build an Extreme Sports Center that accomplishes the same thing.
3,832 views 4 replies
Reply #1 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
I agree with the tetleytea that this is, at the very least, unclear. I suspect the "special" morale projects like the Secret Police Center, and the Galactic Resort are intended to add to base morale as opposed to the more general morale, but I haven't seen any clear evidence that they do.

If they're not intended to add to base morale, then they are completely outclassed by Zero G or higher morale improvements (given that Zero Gs are +30% to morale, and Virtual Reality Centers are +40%). If they ARE intended to add to base morale, they need to at very least be clarified. The description for the Secret Police Center suggests that it adds to /base/, but the Galactic Resort doesn't even do that. Either way, tetleytea suggests that they are NOT adding to base morale, whether or not they're intended to.
Start11 - Customize the Start Menu and Taskbar in Windows 10/11.
Reply #3 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
I don't believe the numbers work out either way. The formula for morale that is stated on the galciv2 wiki (which may, or may not be accurate) is:

fMorale = fCivABilityFactor + fBaseMorale + fImprovementFactor + fPlanetMoraleBonusFactor - fNegativeTreasuryFactor + fPlanetQualityBonus - fTaxModifier

The only two factors we really care about in this example are fBaseMorale, and fImprovementFactor.

fBaseMorale is just = 100 - (% penalty due to population)

fImprovementFactor is just = fBaseMorale * (sum of all morale improvement % bonuses on the plant)

So look at it this way -- when Tetleytea added the Secret Police Center, here is how our two factors could have changed:

EITHER

a) (new)fBaseMorale = (100 - (pop penalty))*1.2
This is what you're suggesting.
You can reduce this equation to:
(new)fBaseMorale = (old)fBaseMorale + .20*(old)fBaseMorale

OR

b) (new)fImprovementFactor = (old)fBaseMorale * .20
This would be if the Police Center is being treated as a regular improvement.

If you think about it, either way, the total Morale calculation is being increased by the same amount -- (old)fBaseMorale * .20. Because the morale equation just adds (or subtracts) in each factor once it's calculated, this means that either way of calculation adds the SAME amount of morale. This makes no sense -- if "adding to base morale" were truly calculated this way, it would be useless -- since it would result in no more of an increase than a regular improvement with the same bonus would.

No, "adding to base morale" only makes sense as something that is better than an ordinary improvement (and thus worthy of being a galactic improvement) if the bonus is simply /added/ to base morale like thus:

(new)fBaseMorale = (old)fBaseMorale + .20

Because the entire equation is summed, this SHOULD result in a straightforward 20% increase in the planet's morale.
Reply #4 from GalCiv2 Forums Top
I expected the Police Center to add a straight 20% increase, just because I didn't have any other morale improvements on that planet. When I did add a Zero G, though, it added the same 19% improvement whether or not I had a Police Center, suggesting that the Police Center was just adding a regular 20% and not base.

If something adds 20% to base morale, I expect morale to jump AT LEAST 20%, or more. It was less.