Later on fertility centers or pure economy buildings yield better results.
Fertility center is +25% growth whereas recruiting center is 20% growth and 10% economic. While you can argue that a stock market is superior to a recruiting center, the instances where you'd rather have a fertility center than a recruiting center are few and far between.
But as you can stack fertility centers, rather than the one-per-planet limit of the recruiting center, of course it is technically better.
The other reason people use the recruiting center is because it's so cheap-it only costs 25 production to build. (Granted, so do fertility clinics, but you don't have access to them as early.)