I think this medal appeals to a certain segment of folks that feels it makes a statement. I think if earned appropriately the medal has value, if not then it doesn't. This really is not that different from any other medal.
Well although I was suppose to get a *real* Purple Heart; because of being in a jeep accident while in a war zone when I was posted to Camp Holloway in Pleiku Vietnam. At the time I refused it; because the jeep wreak was not part of a combat mission; but rather I wound the jeep out to tight on a gravel road and it fish tailed and I rolled it up into an empty ammo bunker.
My

(executive officer, 2nd in command) told me that any time a soldier loosed blood in a combat zone he qualifies for a Purple Heart. I informed him that I though it would cheapen the medal for those that won it for being wounded in an *actual* combat situation. The

, said that it really didn't matter; because the regulations stipulated that the purple was to be given to *ALL* service personnel that lost blood in a combat zone regardless of how the blood was lost.
I continued to refuse it, and he said that he could not force me to take it; but that his opinion was that in later life I would regret not taking it, and guess what he is right. I also found out that any Purple heart recipient gets $10 a month for the rest of his life. I know that isn't any big deal; but now I am trying to get a service connected disability; because of all the physical problem I am having associated from that wreak.
Any how; because of a lot of service personnel having their records destroyed by a fire in either Missouri or Illinois (I can not remember which), the Veterans Administration could not find any proof of my having a jeep wreak or of being in a coma for 3 days. They denied the claim back in 1983 and did what they call a final adjudication which means that it could not be re-opened unless or until I could *prove* that the jeep wreak was factual.
Well to make a long story a tad shorter. After the advent of the Web, I tracked down my old

, yes the same one that said I would regret refusing the purple heart, he sent me a notarized letter on Department of Defense letterhead, countersigned by the Major under him (my old

is currently in charge of the Army's Combat Readiness Center), to both myself and my VA DAV (Disabled American Veterans) rep.
My DAV rep and I sent it in and the VA re-opened my claim because I needed to send them "New and Material Evidence" before a finally adjudicated claim could be opened. Any way had I accepted the Purple Heart in the first place I would have had the proof of the jeep wreak; because on a Medal Citation it gives all the reasons surrounding the reason for the citation.
So, although I is I guess sort of misplaced vanity (I suppose), I sure would like to see Stardock re-institute the Purple Heart.