@han891
You are right about it being unethical, but you are wrong when you say it's not illegal. That model is copyrighted by the owner. That means using it in the way aggiejohn is, violates international copyright law. Ergo, it's illegal. Believe me, I know a little something about this, as I copyright my work all the time, to try and prevent these types of situations.
Now comparing that to creating something based on the TV show battlestar galactica, that's two very distinct and separate things. The art, and specifically the model, of the battlestar galactica used for the show is copyrighted material by ZOIC studios. But I’m not using that, I’ve made my own mesh, based on visual observations freely licensed by ZOIC via broadcasting them on television.
Now, yes, I am using the intellectual property of battlestar galactica as held by universal studios, HOWEVER, as I am not receiving profit or personal gain by doing so, I am not breaking any trademark laws. And as I’ve stated before, I’m also not using any materials copyrighted by any other party. So in short, my use of the word illegal was well thought out, because that's exactly what it is.
Now as for ruining the sense of sharing in the modeling community, it's not that overdramatic. It's exactly what's happened over the last few years, as more and more people have pirated other people’s works for their own benefit. And it IS precisely why people choose not to release much of their work any more. And I’ve been doing this type of work for over 6 years, I’ve seen it happen, and I’ve seen the progression from free and open sharing, to the tight-lipped holding back that's done today. Is it all aggiejohn's fault? No of course not, but its people, like him, who are doing things like he has done, that have vastly contributed to it.