Hi Mystic,
I imagine that a lot of your suggestions might already be possible once the multiplayer function is introduced. I guess we will have to wait and see what's available after 1.2
I'm not sure about being able to 'control' other races bit though.
Part of this games immersive appeal to me, and I'm sure many, many others, is that the 'AI' actually draws you into the game. The unpredictability, and, come to think of it, predictability of a race, once you "get to know them during a game" is excellent.
Ordering them to help / not help, might kinda take away the 'independence' feel to races. Why be allied if you don't want help? Simply breaking the alliance might be an option there. Besides, a race would probably feel insulted that you think yourself so superior to not need/want their help, and whilst it could be introduced as an optional "send message" I think there should be consequences.
I have given more thought to the "Empire Surrender" situation too.
Maybe, and I'm just spit-balling here.. The race about to surrender could ask for sanctuary/protection. They would be in a state of "annexation" (if there is such a term)
Maybe it could work exactly as it is, but the protecting empire would not have access to the planets themselves. A portion of revenue could be diverted to the protecting empire whilst that race attempted to rebuild. Maybe it could last for say 5 years, with the annexed race deciding to stay annexed or not, depending on how they are treated etc. During annexation they might request ships/technology etc.
Of course, any further declarations of war on the annexed race would immediatly be a declaration of war on the protecting empire, so there would (and should) be some risk,. The odd planet may decide to go it alone, spawning a new Minor, and a host of other things might be possible... but it would certainly, to me at least, make a more natural progression through the game than simply beeing handed a virtual "win by default" after a lot of hard (enjoyable) work to get to a certain point.
Maybe the odd planet might 'like' being annexed and want to stay with the protecting empire... the possible options are endless.
I just think on this single issue It's a little like (and this is just a though) like... well a lack of 'end-game.' It's like, "ok you played long enough, time to wrap it up" It all changes so drasticly, and suddenly, that (at the risk of repeating myself) it's a whole different game.
Anyway, enough ranting... I have the "hideous Antarans to crush... oh and that ugly race, you know... the other hideous ones...errr... oh yeah! The Terrans !
Regards as always,
AOD-Bradford