Insensitivity.
End of KrdaxDrkrun's quote
I prefer blunt truthfulness. There is a point at which sugarcoating things simply doesn't work, and can even be detrimental.
Based on the current information, I doubt it's possible for him to get more depressed. But giving up will extend the issue throughout his life, never knowing exactly how it could have been if he'd kept to it. Until she says there is absolutely not chance for anything to happen again, it's not over. (Maybe not even then, depends on if she means it.)
End of Twilight_Storm's quote
I think that, considering the current situation, it's simply not going to happen. I mean, for them to form a lasting, committed relationship, marriage is the best option. It's not even a case of "let's get a piece of paper blahblah" or "let's declare our love to the world blahblah".
It's a case of "this is representing the fact that we are indeed committed to this relationship".
And to do that they'd either need to both get parental permission, both be emancipated, or both be 18+ years old. Ordered in increasing likelihood, mind you.
At this point, I think it would be far better for him to give up, at least for now, and maybe revisit it sometime in the future. Because right now this is simply too emotionally damaging to him for his own good.
I have my opinion, you have yours. I'm helping Xer0 the best way I can, not debating with the two of you on whether or not I'm right.
End of Twilight_Storm's quote
I was under the impression that it was simply criticism, and not debate.
Anyways, IMO, I think we should find out where he lives, observe him in-situ (without telling him we're doing so), communicate via PM to discuss the results of said observation, and then approach him in-person to tell him what we have determined is best for him.
If we each have a different opinion, then we present said opinions.
Fairly obviously, this isn't going to happen.....at least not anytime soon.