Mumblefratz, for "loophole" perhaps read "bug". Maybe there's an extremely freakish combination of results that lead to division by a very small number in the scoring calculation? Very unlikely though, given it's only happened twice.
I'm still not buying it.
First off it's happened more than twice it's just that there are only two known players that have gotten such results but each has multiple occurrences of unbelievable results. The fact that a "bug" has occurred multiple times but to only two players adds to the incredulity.
There are two games that stand out like a sore thumb but there are more games that are in the realm of the unbelievable.
Besides the 2 year small galaxy 2 million point game, Spacetimer also has a 375K and a 450K small galaxy game and both are unbelieveable in their own right. Also Spacetimer has a 1 year small galaxy *tech* win at *beginner* that scored 94K. This too is unachieveable by the best players in the game. Four games all in the space of a single week after not submitting a game for 14 months all of which are well beyond the abilities of the highest scoring players that are known to the forum. Then nothing.
As for DJMJB, in this case it's a brand new username created about a week ago. Take a look at the MV profile and you be the judge.
A defeat on a gigantic cakewalk followed by two cheat flags on 0 year tiny galaxy Suicidals (probably the less than 12 week cheat), followed by a pair of normal looking 27K and 17K tiny galaxy games topped off by 4 games out of the realm of the believable. 3 tiny galaxies at 450K, 204K and 138K at challenging, suicidal and cakewalk. With the small galaxy 1.4 million point game in between.
Even the difficulty gives it away. Who beats suicidal and then decides to step down to cakewalk. There are thousands of MV profiles, I defy anyone to find a single profile where someone that beats suicidal decides to play cakewalk. It's never happened before.
I do appreciate your playing devils advocate because these are very serious accusations and the utmost care and concern should be taken before going to these extremes. However, with all due care and concern and with the shared knowledge of everyone on these forums there really is no other logical conclusion to reach.